Is the Tree Unlawful for Its Nightingales?

Translation / Interpretation / Caption Text / Source
Arabic translation: Is the tree unlawful for its nightingales? Yet permitted to all other birds?62 years since the NakbaCurator's Note: This line of poetry comes from Ahmad Shawqi's poem "Siniyyah". Above the child in the sky are the names of Palestinian cities and destroyed villages.
Arabic
English
Admin Notes

Begin forwarded message:

From: Rochelle Davis
Date: October 13, 2010 10:40:11 PM EDT
To: Nehad Khader
Cc: Dan Walsh
Subject: Re: I struggled with this and I know it way off....D PS: will you be sending those reports soon?

The rest of the poem is in this article, I think.
I didn't open it up, but you should be able to find it here ...
I think it is the poem that has the "is the tree unlawful for its nightingales..."
The Lost Garden of al-Andalus: Islamic Spain and the Poetic ...

by Y Noorani - 1999 - Cited by 5 - Related articles
before, in 1919, the Egyptian Arabic poet Ahmad Shawqi (1868-1932) ended his five-year exile in Spain with a ..... Is the tree unlawful for its nightingales ...
www.jstor.org/stable/176294 - Similar

On Wed, Oct 13, 2010 at 7:46 PM, Nehad Khader wrote:
Hi Rochelle,

So Dan sent this poster, and the text is a little intense. I know that Ahmad Shawqi wrote the poem at the bottom but I cannot figure out what it means. Perhaps you can help us? Dan tried to translate it under translation, but that doesn't seem right.

http://www.palestineposterproject.org/poster/it-is-forbidden-for-him-to-...

Thanks! Nehad.

2010/9/23 Dan Walsh
http://www.palestineposterproject.org/poster/it-is-forbidden-for-him-to-...

--
Rochelle Davis
Assistant Professor, Culture and Society
Center for Contemporary Arab Studies
Georgetown University
http://ccas.georgetown.edu